Looming Pension Costs — An Explanation

The Illinois Public Pension Fund Association takes issue with Gerald Terry’s letter on behalf of the Northwest Municipal Conference regarding the escalating costs of the Public Safety pension system. Apparently Mr. Terry is entirely unaware of the recent studies performed by the Illinois Municipal League which provide a complete explanation as to why the municipal contributions to ensure adequate funding of these retirement funds have continued to grow.

Funding of public retirement programs is required by statute for all systems in the State and all of the State systems use an independent actuary to determine the funding requirements based upon statutory guidelines. The Illinois Department of Insurance (DOI) annually calculates the required contribution to fund the public safety plans. These calculations are often not used to determine the tax levies by the municipalities who choose to retain independent actuaries for these calculations.

But the problem is more systemic. Despite the ability to select an independent actuary, many municipalities choose not to follow the recommendations of the actuaries that they select and do not contribute the mandated contributions.

In 1993, the funding statute was modified to change the method of amortization of unfunded actuarial liabilities. Studies by DOI staff at that time calculated that this change in methodology would result in the following outcome: If every actuarial assumption used in funding were exactly realized (a virtually impossible scenario), then the unfunded actuarial liability would increase 300% in 12-years (simply because of the lower payments) and then would begin its decline to 0% by 2033.

We are not unsympathetic to the burden passed on to taxpayers for properly funding the municipal pension programs. Strong management requires a recognition that pension funding should occur while the pensions are being earned and not passed off to future generations of taxpayers.

It is now unseemly for these same municipalities to raise issues which were anticipated and to attempt to blame the system for performing exactly as anticipated; and, rather hypocritical to be presenting results when the municipalities themselves appear to be primarily responsible for these results.


IPPFA Consolidation of Pension Funds Investment Authority Fact Sheet 2019
The Impact of Easing Investment Restrictions on Downstate Illinois Police and Fire Pension Funds2019
Illinois Downstate Pension Fund Consolidation - Costs and Savings from Consolidating Police and Fire Pension Funds2019
Illinois Pension Fund Systems Expense Rankings2019
All Illinois Retirement Systems 2018 Benefit and Expense Data2019
Amendment to Consolidation Senate Bill - Filed 10/2/20192019
Illinois Pension Consolidation Feasibility Task Force Report - October 10, 20192019
New studies show simple way to improve local pension funds and warn of consolidation pitfalls2019
Why is There a Pension Clause to Protect Illinois Public Employees? (From the Lawsuit Filed by the We Are One Coalition of Illinois on January 28, 20142014
Constitutionality of Cutting Pension Benefits for Current State Workers2011
Houston Firefighters Pension Fund Chair Speaks with Members2011
WeAreOne Rally a Huge Success: Check out the Video, Thank You for Your Support2011
The Underfunding of State and Local Pensions Plansn.a.
The Looming Crisis in the States2010
The Illusion of Pension Savings2010
Sun Times Takes Flawed Pension Story to WTTW2009
"Firefighters are Street People:" a Must Listen to Recording as the Village of Oak Brook, IL Discusses its Firefighter Problem2010
Significant Reforms in State Retirement Systems by NASRA2014
Pensionomics 2014: Measuring the Economic Impact of DB Pension Expenditures2014
Pension Pressures Continue - Special Report: 2014 State Pension Update2014
2014 We Are One Illinois vs State of Illinois (SB1)2014
Public Pension Plan Reform: The Legal Framework2013
Overview of SB1 by Bukola Bello IPPFA Consultant2013
State and Local Pension Costs: PRECRISIS, POST-CRISIS, and POST-REFORM2013
State and Local Goverrnments Focus on Pension Funding Policy2013
The State of Illinois Summary of Pension Plans2013
Moody's Proposal to Adjust Pension Liability, Asset, and Cost Information Reported by State and Local Goverments and Their Pension Plans2013
2013 Report on the Financial Condition of the Downstate Police and Fire Pension Funds in Illinois2013
Pension Litigation Summary2013
State and Local Pensions 1012013
The Buck Stays Here: Understanding the Economic Impact of Chicago Teachers' Pension Fund Benefit Payments on the State of Illinois and the City of Chicago2012
Unappreciated: Illinois Public Workers are Facing a Morale Crisis by Robert Bruno2012
The Great Recession: Pressures on Public Pensions, Reforms, and Employment Relations2012
Letter by The American Academy of Actuaries to Senator: Hatch on State and Local Government Defined Benefit Pension Plans2012
Proposed Statement of the Governmental Accounting Standards Board: Plain-Language Supplement Pension Accounting and Financial Reporting2012
The 80% Pension Funding Standard Myth2012
Executive Office of the President Council of Economic Advisors: Supporting Retirement for American Families2012
National Association of State Retirement Administrators ISSUE BRIEF: State and Local Government Spending on Public Employee Retirement Systems2012
Constitutional Issues when Altering Public Pension Benefits2012
Republican Governors Public Policy Committee - Pension Reform Catalogue2012
Who has a Pension?2012
The Role Public Pensions on the Economy and for Employers, Taxpayers, Employees, and Retirees2012
GASB Reporting vs Pension Funding2012
The Funding of State and Local Pensions: 2011-20152012
AFSCME's Response to Mayor Emanuel's Presentation to the House Personnel and Pension Committee on May 8, 20122012
Chicago Mayor Emanuel Remarks to the Members of the Personnel and Pension Committee on May 8, 20122012
Illinois Department of Insurance Public Pension Division: Public Pension Report (2009-2010)2012
COGFA: Financial Condition of the Illinois State Retirement Systems as of June 30, 20112012
State and Local Government Pension Plans: Economic Downturn Spurs Efforts to Address Costs and Sustainability2012
Pensionomics 2012: Measuring the Economic Impact of DB Pension Expenditures2012
NASRA ISSUE BRIEF: State and Local Government Spending on Public Employee Retirement Systems2012
Illinois Public Pension Plans - Discussion Forum2012
National Trends in Public Pensions by James McNamee2012
Who Gets Retirement Plans and Why, 2010 by Investment Company Institute2012
Public Pension Policy in Illinois - An Introduction to a Crucial Issue2012
Lessons Learned: the Inaugural Year of Say-on-Pay2012
Hatch Report: State and Local Government Defined Benefit Pension Plans2012
Illinois Department of Revenue Research Division, Fiscal Year 2012 Revenue Report2012
The Tax Policy Briefing Book, 20082012
Misunderstandings Regarding State Debt, Pensions, and Retiree Health Costs Create Unnessary Alarm2012
Center on Budge and Policy Priorities: a Common-Sense Strategy for Fixing State Pension Problems in Tough Economic Times2012
Diane Oakley, Executive Director at NIRS, Submitted Letter to Associated Press Sacramento Bureau Chief2012
Faulty Analysis is Unhelpful to State and Local Pension Sustainability Efforts - Part 12011
How would GASB Proposals Affect State and Local Pension Reporting?2011
Pensions and Retirement Plan Enactments in 2011 State Legislatures (09/2011)2011
More Faulty Pension Analysis Unhelpful to State and Local Recovery Efforts - Part 22011
Who Gets Retirement Plans and Why, 20102011
Unions and Public Pensions: This Brief Identifies the Impact of Public Sector Unions and Other Factors on Benefit Levels, Wages, and Employment2011
National Institute of Retirement Security Testifies Before U.S. Senate that Pensions Create Jobs, Stimulate the Economy2011
An Update on Locally Administered Pension Plans2011
A Report on the Appropriateness of the 90% Funding Target of Public Act 88-5932011
SB 0512 Passed out of Committee (6 to 2); Call your Legislator Today and Ask them to Vote NO2011
SB 1831 Amendment 001 - That Would Affect Article 3 and Article 4 Pension Funds2011
Pension Truth We Are One2011
ILFOP Call to Action2011
Setting the Record Straight about Public Pensions2011
Addressing Media Misconceptions about Public Sector Pensions and Bankruptcy2011
Lies, Damned Lies, and Statistics2011
2011 State Pension Reform Proposals2011
Is Welching on Public Pension Promises an Option for Illinois? Entire2011
Who Killed the Private Sector DB Plan?2011
Illinois Pension Crisis in a Nutshell by Anthony Martin2011
National Legislative Report2011
Facts on State and Local Government Pensions2011
Analysis: Attacks on Public Sector by Marshal Auerback2011
COGFA Report - Overview of Key Provisions of SB 3538 HA#3 (Starts on Page 13)2011
The Impact of Public Pensions on State and Local Budgets2010
SB 3538 Legal Update by IPPFA General Counsel Rick Reimer2010
Message from President McNamee - SB 3538 Passed Both Chambers Today (12-02-2010)2010
2011-11 Pension Legislation Update from President McNamee2010
New Interactive Map Shows Pension Reforms2010
NCPERS - Public Pension Defense Toolkit Template2010
IRSI - Perserving Retirement Security2010
Pension Problems? Not Here2010
Public Pension Basics2010
AFFI Response to the Southern by Pat Devaney - President of AFFI - Ever Wonder about Mayor's Cole Pension?2010
Federal Reserve Bank: Public Pensions and Labor Supply Over the Life Cycle2010
Three Myths about Local and State Government Pension Plans2010
Public Pension Defense Toolkit Template2010
Out of Balance? Comparing Public and Private Sector Compensation over 20 Years2010
Article: SEC Charges State of New Jersey with Securites Fraud Involving Pension Funding2010
Court Case: SEC Charges State of New Jersey with Securities Fraud Involving Pension Funding2010
Pension Rights Center - Retirement Income Deficit2010
Critique of Joshua Rauh's Paper, "Are State Public Pensions Sustainable?"2010
Oak Brook Pension Board Response to Oak Brook Village Board Resolution2010
IRSI Response to The Southern by Bukola Bello, Director of the IRSI2010
Letter to the Editor by Daniel Nelson, Director of Government Affairs - FOP State Lodge2010
Sample Letter to Editor by Dan Kaplan2010
The Role of Defined Benfits Plans in the Venture Capital System2010
The Wage Penalty for State and Local Government Employees2010
The Wage Penalty for State and Local Government Employees2010
Pension Overhaul Decimates Benefits for Future Hires by IRSI2010
IPPFA vs State of Illinois - Illinois Supreme Court Case Number 79592n.a.
Art Tepfer Addidavit in Support of IPPFA Motion (Illinois Supreme Court Case Number 79592)n.a.
Letter to the Editor of the Lake County News Sun by Jeffrey Welch2010
CTBA - The True Story about Pension Funds2010
IPPFA Response to Illinois Municipal League Commentary on the COGFA Report2010
COGFA - Fiscal Analysis of the Downstate Police and Fire Pension Funds in Illinois2009
COGFA - Fiscal Analysis of the Downstate Police and Fire Pension Funds in Illinois2010
The Pew Report - Overview2010
Letter to the Editor of the Peoria Journal Star by IPPFA Deputy Counsel James Dobrovolny2010
The Role of Public Pensions on the Economy2010
The Role of Public Pensions on the Economy2010
Illinois is the Worst in the Nation for Funding Pensions2010
The Trillion Dollar Gap - Underfunded State Retirement Systems and the Roads to Reform2010
Letter to the Editor by Bukola Bello of IRSI2010
Actuarial Funding Problem2010
Cash-Strapped Municipalities Look to Springfield in Search of Pension Solutions2009
Villages Brace for Pension Fund Fallout in 20102009
Looming Pension Costs: an Explanation2009
The Story is Pensions, not Firefighters2009
Why is it Time to Retire the 401(k)?2009
Letter to the City Manager of Naperville from Naperville Pension Board2010